[NSIS] Point 2: dictates that encapsulation of the original initiator QSPEC ...

>> Point_2: dictates that encapsulation of the original initiator QSPEC 
>> feature cannot be used in combination with the tunneling (parallel
>> session) feature.
>> 
>> In the discussion that we have had in the nsis mailing list and
during 
>> the IETF meeting it was stated that both these features should be 
>> possible, while now version 13 of the QSPEC template draft dictates 
>> that these two features cannot be used together and at the same time 
>> by the same QoS model.
>> As I mentioned in all the discussions the encapsulation of the 
>> original QSPEC feature is needed to satisfy Requirement:
>> "5.4.2.  It SHOULD be Possible to Add and Remove Local Domain 
>> Information" given in: http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3726.txt
>> Therefore the encapsulation (of the original initiator QSPEC into a
local
>> QSPEC) feature should be seen as an independent feature and it should

>> be able to be used in combination with the tunneling (parallel 
>> session) feature that is used for another goal.
>> 
>> Thus my proposal is that it should be mentioned that even when the 
>> tunneling (parallel session) feature is used, it is also allowed to 
>> use, at the same time, the encapsulation (of the original initiator 
>> QSPEC into a local QSPEC) feature in order to satisfy Requirement
>> 5.4.2 of RFC
>> 3726.
>
>I don't see a reason to preclude using, at the same time, both 
>1. tunneling a QSPEC through a local domain by initiating a 
>new RESERVE at the domain edge, AND 2. defining a local QSPEC 
>and encapsulating the initiator QSPEC, as defined in Section 
>5.1 of the QSPEC draft 
>http://ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-nsis-qspec-13.txt.
>
>Georgios provided an example based on the RMD-QOSM of when it 
>would be necessary to use both features at the same time.  I 
>think we're in agreement here.

I agree as well.

John

_______________________________________________
nsis mailing list
nsis@ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/nsis